This episode explores one of the original fake new items of the late 19th Century, a made-up disease that affected women (and some men) called “Bicycle Face”.
This episode explores one of the original fake new items of the late 19th Century, a made-up disease that affected women (and some men) called “Bicycle Face”.
If you would like to support the podcast, you and Buy Me a Coffee
Listen to the lyric video for Sticks and Stones Lyric Video on YouTube
The History Detective Season 1 & 2 Album is now available on Spotify and all of your music streaming services.
Accompanying teaching resources for season 1 and 2 episodes can be found on my Amped Up Learning Store or on my Teachers Pay Teachers store.
Accompanying teaching resources can be purchased from my Amped Up Learning Store
Season One Cover Lesson Bundle
Reflection Questions
Contact: Twitter @HistoryDetect, Instagram @HistoryDetective9, email historydetective9@gmail.com
All original music written and performed by Kelly Chase.
Hi, this is Kelly Chase and you are listening to History Detective, a podcast where I delve into the past to uncover the mysteries of history and then I explore how that story might be reimagined through song. This is Case 5: Poetry in Motion.
(Rabbit Hole Music 1🎼)
Introduction
If you are an Australian of a certain age, as a child, you would have been drip fed a steady diet of the Australian poet Banjo Patterson and at the very least you can quote, “T’was Mulga Bill from Eagle Hawk who caught the cycling craze.” But it wasn’t just men who caught the cycling craze, women of 1896 also discovered the joy of cycling and hence doctors of the time warned women that if they rode bicycles, they were in very real danger of developing an affliction. So today we will be exploring one of the original fake new items of the late 19th Century, a made-up disease that affected women (and some men) called “Bicycle Face”.
(Transition music🎼)
Story Time
Before we launch into the fictitious symptoms of bicycle face, we need to explore what life was like for women at the time. What I like to call very important context. In my clicking and scrolling though newspapers and magazines on Trove, I kept seeing references to a woman called Mrs Grundy, or Mother Grundy. I thought to myself, who on earth is this Mrs Grundy, she seemed to very judgmental of this scandalous cycling behaviour.
It turns out that she too made up. I guess journalists of the time could evoke her name to show they disagreed with some new-fangled pastime or other. Like in the case of, “What would Mrs Grundy say?” In one article she is to have said, “that fashionable sensations do not last as long as granite.” And let’s face it, she’s kind of right.
However, in many cases her name was used to show a kind of edgy journalism, showing the perspective of the modern thinking society who laughed in the face of the old fuss pot Mrs Grundy. The opening line of an article called “Bicycling for Women” written by “A doctor’s wife” asks, “Is Mrs Grundy dead? Or has she gone to some far-off planet, where they still enjoy the "good old days" …of long ago? … she could never live happily in this …world, which the present bicycle craze is turning topsy-turvy to such an alarming extent that members of the "gentler" sex, ride in "bloomers." The article goes on to discuss how healthy bike riding is and how it makes life easier. I do want to point out that this writer does not have her name published and is only referred to by her relation to her husband and his occupation. But I guess they are trying to get the audience to trust her because, after all, she was only a woman, and women were not even worthy of voting at this time. Another article’s author in signing off, uses Italics and says simply Lady. (Full stop.) This is now my new favourite way of ending a letter. I may adopt this in my email correspondence. I think Mrs Grundy would approve.
Confession time, sometimes I have to curtail my inner Mrs Grundy, but only because I can barely keep up with the latest technological trends.
The doctor’s wife made mention of bloomers. If you look it up on Trove, there are 122 thousand newspaper articles that reference bloomers in the decade of 1880-1889. And many of these articles also mention cyclists or cycling. For those who are too young to have owned a pair, bloomers are a kind of loose ¾ pant that are gathered in at the knees and you might see them on an old-fashioned doll. You see fashion up until this point, was very restrictive in terms of movement for women, it consisted corsets and of long heavy skirts that were completely impractical for doing any kind of activity that involved more than minimal movement of the legs. So, the introduction of bicycles, also opened up a conversation about fashion reform. The very fact that I can pop down to my spin class in my active wear is all thanks to the brave ladies of the 80s, 1880s that is, boldly donning their bloomers to ride carefree through the streets on their infernal machines. Scandalous!
(Transition music🎼)
Digging Deeper
But let’s get down to the nitty gritty of “Bicycle Face”. A few years ago, I was listening to an audiobook about the women’s suffrage movement called “You Daughters of Freedom” by Dr Clare Wright- I highly recommend it by the way. And in chapter 24, there was a one-line reference to “Bicycle Face”. This stopped me in my tracks, and I immediately ran to the Trove website and fell into a very deep and amusing rabbit hole. The first article I read was a double whammy about restrictions on women, it was called, “Do you Tipple? A chat on Various topics.” Tippling is drinking alcohol. The writer asserts, “Whenever I see a young lady lifting the champagne glass to her lips I am taken with a cold shiver.” And then goes on to say, “Once women get a love for wine and spirits, they are doomed.” Luckily this author is no longer with us to shudder at the doomed lasses who go clubbing in Surfers Paradise on a Friday night.
The article then goes on to discuss how a well-known Sydney doctor is warning of the perils of bicycle riding. Because of the fear of collision with the many obstacles that the city presents women cyclists such as, trams and pedestrians, “it does not take long for her to develop bicycle face.” This article is the perfect example of how a source can be not particularly reliable, but very useful in demonstrating the attitudes and beliefs about women at the time. His evidence for this diagnosis is “you only have to observe a woman riding through any street to see how her legs are going and her eyes are fixed.” The afore mentioned Lady. (full stop) agrees, “If not corrected in time, the face gradually settles into a haunted, drawn look, the brows become contracted, and there is a rigid appearance about the eyes.” Adding further, “I never think a woman looks her best on a bicycle.”
But don’t think that this malady was confined to the face, no, the more you rode, the more likely that other parts of your body would become afflicted. Your hands could become infected. This description paints a particularly vivid picture, “the bicycle hand is a thing of ugliness and a horror for ever." The distinctive features of this hand are stated to be that "it becomes flattened, bulges out at the sides, gets lumpy and out of shape, and the fingers all become crooked.”
You also had to take care that your feet didn’t become afflicted. One article managing to be both sexist and racist explains, baby girls often walk like Indians, with their feet pointing together in a V and proclaims that although this can be overcome, if a girl takes up riding a bicycle, this condition will reassert itself. It ends with the advice “watch one next time she dismounts, you will see her pigeon-toeing and leaving crow tracks upon the dust of the road.”
Of course, not all of the articles were against women riding a bike. Many were written tongue in cheek and recognised the ridiculousness of these claims. Several were touting the health benefits of riding a bike. “Let women cultivate health (says a high medical authority), …, and men will value them more.” This statement is of course still framed to highlight women’s value to men, but at least it is support. He does go on to worry that they will lose their graceful outlines. However, my favourite is the following description, “the bicycle girl flits by him, her trim ankles glancing in the sunlight and her fine figure poised in graceful equilibrium.” Nothing like a glance of a trim ankle in the sunlight.
Now we have heard about the detractors and the supporters, what was the big deal about girls on bikes? Bicycles represented freedom for women, and that in turn represented feminist ideals. Before bicycles became popular if you were a woman and wanted to travel, your options were very limited, walking, a carriage, on horseback. If an upper-class woman was to go outside, they would probably be chaperoned. But the bicycle enabled women to get out into the world and experience a measure of freedom. Not only that, it was a catalyst for women’s dress reform.
An 1899 Australian supporter of dress reform says, “the bicycle may be regarded as the chief dress reformer of the day… Within two years it has given to all American womankind the liberty of dress for which the reformers have been fighting for generations.” The writer does boldly state, “The bicycle has not put many women in trousers—nothing will do that, in this country.” Oh, how wrong you are sir. 121 years later, and us skirt wearers are few and far between, it is trousers all the way for many female folk.
There is a wonderful cartoon in the American Library of Congress that backs up this point titled “The bicycle - the great dress reformer of the nineteenth century!” In the background it shows women and men dressed in all manner of ridiculously exaggerated impractical fashion, and in the foreground a man and woman are wearing their cycling bloomers and boots standing beside a bicycle and shaking hands triumphantly.
To this day, in some countries in Africa, and India, there are programs that give bikes to young women so they can overcome barriers in getting to school and work towards gender equality in education.
So maybe Mulga Bill caught the cycling craze, but it was the women who embraced the bicycle and continue to use it as a vehicle of equality and empowerment.
I would love to hear any suggestions for future episodes, so please get in contact. You can follow me on Twitter @HistoryDetect, Instagram @HistoryDetective9 or email me at historydetective9@gmail.com
A special shout out to my RPM instructors Dave and Ellie, who put up with my bicycle face every week. And a big thank you to the National Library of Australia Trove website, whose digitised newspapers have been instrumental in this episode- they even make putting together a bibliography easy.
Now I would like to play you a song that I wrote called Poetry in Motion which was inspired by bicycle face.
This is Kelly Chase on the case.
(Play full song🎼)
Poetry in motion
Verse C, Am
Chorus Dm Am C Am
Verse
An open letter
To a medical man
I’ve upset the balance
Please understand
These dark shadows
Were cast by you
This fixed expression
Is nothing new
Chorus
Change is coming
wheels are moving
Poetry in Motion
Revolution is here
Verse
I‘m drawn to
This infernal machine
It’s given me a taste of
What freedom means
Chorus
Change is coming
wheels are moving
Poetry in Motion
Revolution is here
Look into my wild eyes
What do you see?
a glint of hope
our daughters will be free
Chorus
Change is coming
wheels are moving
Poetry in Motion
Revolution is here
Verse
an open letter
To a medical man
I’m just a lady
Please understand
Reflection Questions
If you are a teacher or student, you will find reflection questions in the show notes. A link to the transcript, the song lyrics and a list of references are linked in the show notes.
(Find transcript here) https://history-detective.simplecast.com/
Next time on History Detective (Transition music🎼)
Next time on History Detective, we will meet the Perfume River Squad, the female combat fighters and spies who fought in the Vietnam War.
Episodes are released every fortnight, and if you liked what you heard and know someone who might enjoy History Detective too, please share it and don’t forget to subscribe.
Bibliography
1895 'A Lady's Bicycle Ride.', Weekly Times (Melbourne, Vic. : 1869 - 1954), 23 February, p. 15. , viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article220542136
1895, The Bulletin, Vol. 16 No. 820 (2 Nov 1895), Sydney, N.S.W.: John Haynes and J.F. Archibald, viewed 31 Jul 2020
1896 'BICYCLING FOR WOMEN.', The Kyneton Observer (Vic. : 1856 - 1900), 10 October, p. 3., viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article240666335
1896 'Pigeon Toes.', National Advocate (Bathurst, NSW : 1889 - 1954), 18 February, p. 2. , viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article156719650
1897 'THE BICYCLE AND DRESS.', The Sunbury News and Bulla and Melton Advertiser (Vic. : 1892 - 1900), 28 August, p. 3. , viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article66883484
1897 'THE BICYCLE FACE.', Adelaide Observer (SA : 1843 - 1904), 28 August, p. 32. , viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article162380174
1896 'THE BICYCLE "HAND."', Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners' Advocate (NSW : 1876 - 1954), 9 November, p. 4. , viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article135769784
1896 'WOMEN'S VIEWS.', Sunday Times (Sydney, NSW : 1895 - 1930), 25 October, p. 8. , Access Date 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article130401002
1898 'CYCLING AND CYCLISTS.', South Australian Register (Adelaide, SA : 1839 - 1900), 22 October, p. 4. , viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article56546749
1899 'A DRESS REFORMER.', The Armidale Express and New England General Advertiser (NSW : 1856 - 1861; 1863 - 1889; 1891 - 1954), 13 June, p. 2. , viewed 31 Jul 2020, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article193358559
Abrahams, J, 2015, Freewheeling to equality: how cycling helped women on the road to rights, The Guardian, Access Date 31 July 2020 https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/womens-blog/2015/jun/18/freewheeling-equality-cycling-women-rights-yemen-bicycle-liberation
Ehrhart, S.J,1895, The bicycle - the great dress reformer of the nineteenth century! Illus. from Puck, v. 37, no. 961, (1895 August 7), centerfold. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA, Access date, 31 July 2020, http://loc.gov/pictures/resource/ppmsca.29031/
Stromberg, J, 2015, "Bicycle face": a 19th-century health problem made up to scare women away from biking, Vox Media, Access Date 30 July 2020,
Thorpe, JR, 2017, The Feminist History Of Bicycles, Bustle Digital Group, Access Date 30 July 2020, https://www.bustle.com/p/the-feminist-history-of-bicycles-57455